The Ultimate Mac Eyeshadow Drugstore Dupes List [15 Popular Shades]
Looking for the best mac eyeshadow dupes that will save you some major moolah?
Well, you’ve come to the right place!
Mac eyeshadows are well worth the money in my opinion, because of their amazing quality, stunning and complex shades, and overall texture and blendability.
However, there are some really great dupes out there that are virtually identical in color, longevity, pigmentation, and formula that will knock your socks off.
Whether you opt for the mac eyeshadows or their more affordable drugstore dupes (or a few of each like I have), you really can’t go wrong.
Do what works best for your needs and budget.
Without further ado, let’s hop right into these amazing drugstore dupes for popular (and some discontinued) mac eyeshadows.
Not enough time to read all of these mac eyeshadow dupes now? Pin this post for later:
This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission if you purchase through my links, at no extra cost to you. Please read the disclosure policy for more information.
Best Mac Eyeshadow Dupes from the Drugstore:
1. MAC Shroom Eyeshadow vs DUPE: wet n wild Walking on Eggshells Palette (Browbone Shade)
First up on this MAC eyeshadow dupes list is a super popular (and usually sold-out) shade.
MAC’s Shroom eyeshadow is a beautiful, shimmery soft beige color.
If you’re looking for a mac shroom eyeshadow dupe that is pretty much identical in shade and is just as perfect at highlighting and brightening, the browbone shade of the wet n wild Walking on Eggshells palette is it!
This palette actually has three incredible dupes for mac eyeshadows – read on below to see what the other two are.
2. MAC Cork Eyeshadow vs DUPE: wet n wild Walking on Eggshells Palette (Crease Shade)
MAC’s Cork eyeshadow is a stunning muted brown shade.
As mentioned above, the wet n wild Walking on Eggshells palette has a mac eyeshadow cork dupe as well!
The crease shade is a stellar mac cork eyeshadow dupe and you’re getting three mac eyeshadow dupes for less than the price of one mac eyeshadow with this amazing drugstore palette.
3. MAC Naked Lunch Eyeshadow vs DUPE: wet n wild Walking on Eggshells Palette (Eyelid Shade)
If you love a muted, shimmery pink shade, then you’ve probably fallen in love with MAC’s Naked Lunch eyeshadow.
The final MAC eyeshadow dupe in the wet n wild Walking on Eggshells palette is the eyelid shade.
It’s a fantastic mac naked lunch eyeshadow dupe and a super affordable alternative (3 dupes for less than the price of one mac shade)!
4. MAC Cranberry Eyeshadow vs DUPE: NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Eyeshadow in Rust
This mac eyeshadow dupes list wouldn’t be complete without some of MAC’s more bold and daring favorites, like MAC’s Cranberry Eyeshadow.
If you’re looking for a super close red plum shade with some shimmer, the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Eyeshadow in Rust is a fantastic mac cranberry eyeshadow dupe.
Overall, there are a lot of fantastic nyx dupes for mac eyeshadows out there because the formulas are awesome and the prices are even more awesome.
5. MAC Carbon Eyeshadow vs DUPE: wet n wild Eyeshadow in Panther
Everyone loves the MAC Carbon eyeshadow because it is a truly deep, dark, and pigmented black shade.
Get the same (maybe even more) pigmentation and drama with the wet n wild Eyeshadow in Panther (a.k.a the most amazing mac carbon eyeshadow dupe ever!)
RELATED POST: Identical Drugstore Dupes For 15 Best Selling MAC Lipstick Shades
6. MAC Tete A Tint Eyeshadow vs DUPE: Colourpop Wake Up Call
If you’re looking for something more neutral and wearable for every day, one of the most popular neutral shades is MAC’s Tete A Tint eyeshadow.
Get the same soft peachy neutral look with Colourpop’s Pressed Powder Shadow in Wake Up Call.
This mac tete a tint eyeshadow dupe is pretty much impossible to tell apart on the lids and both are equally pigmented and long-lasting.
7. MAC Coral Eyeshadow vs DUPE: wet n wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Palette Not a Basic Peach
Want a pretty pop of color, like MAC’s Coral eyeshadow?
The wet n wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Palette in Not a Basic Peach has a coral color that is a spot-on mac coral eyeshadow dupe that you can’t miss out on.
This comparison shows just how close the two colors are.
You even get a bunch of other colors in the palette that pair beautifully with the coral shade.
The best part?
You get 10 incredibly stunning and good quality eyeshadows in that palette for less than the cost of the single mac eyeshadow!
8. MAC All That Glitters Eyeshadow vs DUPE: Makeup Geek Rekindle
The MAC All That Glitters eyeshadow is one of the most popular and infamous MAC eyeshadows because it’s so universally flattering.
Makeup Geek’s Rekindle eyeshadow is a fabulous mac all that glitters eyeshadow dupe.
This mac all that glitters dupe from makeup geek has the same beige tone with gold pearl shimmer, making it a super close shade match at a much more affordable price.
9. MAC Nylon Eyeshadow vs DUPE: Colourpop Eyeshadow in Palm Reader
MAC’s Nylon eyeshadow is the perfect pale gold color with an icy shimmer.
A mac nylon eyeshadow dupe is one of the most searched for mac eyeshadow dupes on the internet, because of how hard it is to find an affordable alternative.
Well, I’m here to tell you that a mac nylon eyeshadow dupe does truly exist and it’s the Colourpop Eyeshadow in Palm Reader.
While this mac nylon eyeshadow dupe comes as part of the Going Coconuts palette, it’s still much more affordable than the mac eyeshadow alone.
You also get another eight beautiful, pigmented and high-quality eyeshadows to choose from in the palette!
If you’re looking for a mac nylon eyeshadow dupe that is sold individually, then Makeup Geek’s Telepathic eyeshadow is another great alternative and shade match.
10. MAC Satin Taupe Eyeshadow vs DUPE: L’Oreal Shadow in Bronzed Taupe
MAC’s Satin Taupe is a beautiful taupe shade with silver shimmer.
Check out this mac satin taupe eyeshadow swatch to see just how beautiful and complex the color is.
Despite its complexity, the L’Oreal Shadow in Bronzed Taupe is a fantastic mac satin taupe eyeshadow dupe.
It is a spot-on shade match and has an equally long-lasting and easily blendable formula for much less!
Another dupe for mac satin taupe eyeshadow if that one is unavailable is the wet n wild eyeshadow in nutty (also a super close shade match).
Lastly, if both of those are sold out due to popularity, then the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Iced Mocha is also a solid mac satin taupe eyeshadow dupe from the drugstore.
RELATED POST: 13 Mind-Blowing Charlotte Tilbury Dupes: So Close You’ll Think The Formulas Were Stolen
11. MAC Red Brick Eyeshadow vs DUPE: Colourpop Cannonball Pressed Pigment
MAC’s Red Brick eyeshadow is a stunning orangey-red shade that screams fall to me (but is also amazing for all the seasons!)
If you’re looking for the ultimate mac red brick eyeshadow dupe, then check out Colourpop Cannonball Pressed Pigment.
The shade and formula is virtually identical and you’ll save some cash!
MAC Eyeshadow Drugstore Dupes for Discontinued Shades:
12. MAC Digit Eyeshadow vs DUPE: NYX Prismatic Eyeshadow in Whimsical
MAC’s Digit eyeshadow is a beautiful pearl-finished, cool-toned light lavender color that has sadly been discontinued.
This has left many searching all over the internet for a good mac digit eyeshadow dupe to replace their old favorite.
The NYX Prismatic Eyeshadow in Whimsical is a super affordable mac digit eyeshadow dupe that you (and your wallet) will LOVE.
As mentioned earlier, there are a ton of amazing nyx dupes for mac eyeshadows out there, so if you come across another shade dupe you love I’d highly recommend picking it up.
13. MAC Tempting Eyeshadow vs DUPE: Makeup Geek Intermission
Temptalia describes MAC’s Tempting eyeshadow as a rich, golden bronze with warm undertones and a metallic sheen.
There are a lot of Makeup Geek mac dupes out there that you may have heard of and this is the first of a few for discontinued mac shades.
Makeup Geek’s Intermission is a great mac tempting eyeshadow dupe that is also a beautiful medium rust brown tone.
14. MAC Swish Eyeshadow vs DUPE: Makeup Geek Illusion
MAC’s Swish eyeshadow was loved by many and also has a dupe from Makeup Geek.
Makeup Geek’s Illusion eyeshadow is a stunning light pink shade with gold undertones, making it a fabulous mac swish eyeshadow dupe both in shade and finish.
15. MAC Trax Eyeshadow vs DUPE: Makeup Geek Enchanted
Last but not least on this mac drugstore eyeshadow dupes list is another Makeup Geek mac dupe!
Temptalia describes MAC’s Trax eyeshadow as a sparkly, warm-toned, medium-dark plum.
Makeup Geek’s Enchanted eyeshadow is a beautiful mac trax eyeshadow dupe due to its similar deep plum color and sparkly finish.
MAC Eyeshadow Drugstore Dupes Wrap Up
Fortunately, there’s a ton of amazing mac eyeshadow drugstore dupes out there that provide the same benefits, have some pretty awesome reviews, and help give your wallet a break!
If you have any suggestions or other favorites please feel free to share them with us and our community by commenting below.
Would love to know what else is out there!
If you liked this post, please check out some of my other best drugstore dupes round-ups in the Beauty category of my blog.
Other drugstore dupe posts you’ll love:
12 Affordable Becca Cosmetics Dupes For Discontinued Best-Sellers
13 Spectacular Fenty Beauty Drugstore Dupes That Will Blow Your Mind (Not Your Wallet)
Save Money: 12 Best It Cosmetics Drugstore Dupes You Need ASAP
10 Affordable Benefit Cosmetics Drugstore Dupes To Save Your Wallet
13 Best NARS Makeup Dupes From The Drugstore You Can’t Tell Apart
6 Unbelievable Drugstore Bronzer Dupes To Save You Money
9 Jaw Dropping Drugstore Highlighter Dupes To Save Major Money
19 Best Drugstore Foundation Dupes: Look Beautiful & Save Money