7 Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm Dupes That Feel Identical (And Won’t Break the Bank)

When you’re weighing the original against a Summer Fridays lip butter balm dupe, it really boils down to price versus performance. While the original gives you that proven luxe feel and serious hydration for $24, a ton of amazing dupes now deliver a nearly identical buttery texture, high-shine finish, and deep moisture for under $10.

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission if you purchase through my links, at no extra cost to you. Please read the disclosure policy for more information.

A Quick Look at the Top Summer Fridays Dupes

Dupe Product	Price Point	Best For
Naturium Phyto-Glow Lip Balm	~$10	Closest overall texture and shine
Lanolips 101 Ointment	~$14	Intense, long-lasting hydration
Milani Fruit Fetish Lip Oil	~$11	A high-gloss, juicy finish
e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm	~$4	The most budget-friendly option
Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment	~$16	Skincare benefits with a luxe feel
Tree Hut Sugarlips Lip Butter	~$6	A thick, overnight treatment feel
Tower 28 ShineOn Lip Jelly	~$16	A clean, non-sticky gloss hybrid

Why Everyone Is Searching for a Lip Butter Balm Dupe

If you’ve spent any time on TikTok lately, you've seen it: the Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm is the viral product dominating everyone's feed and makeup bag. It's earned its cult-favorite status for a reason—the silky, non-sticky formula is packed with nourishing Shea and Murumuru butters.

It just melts into your lips, leaving behind a glossy finish that looks like a lip gloss but feels like a deeply hydrating treatment. But that premium price tag has sent beauty lovers on a mission to find a more affordable alternative that doesn’t skimp on quality. The hunt for the perfect dupe isn't just about saving money; it’s about finding that same coveted, luxurious experience without the splurge.

The great news for dupe hunters is that the beauty market is absolutely exploding with options. The global lip balm market was valued at USD 2.47 billion in 2024 and is only expected to grow, which shows just how much we all love our lip care.

This growth pushes brands to create incredible formulas at lower prices, making it easier than ever to find a great Summer Fridays lip butter balm dupe. If you love finding affordable alternatives for cult-favorite products, you might also like our guide to the best Dior Addict Lip Glow dupes.

What Makes The Original Lip Butter Balm a Cult Favorite

To find a genuinely good Summer Fridays lip butter balm dupe, we first have to get real about what makes the original so ridiculously popular. Its rise to holy-grail status wasn't a fluke; it's all down to a specific formula that just works, creating an experience that sets the bar for every other balm trying to compete.

It all starts with that signature buttery texture. Unlike waxy balms that just sit on top of your lips or sticky glosses that feel goopy, this one glides on and immediately melts in, giving you instant relief. This luxe, cushiony feel is the number one thing we're looking for in a dupe.

The Powerhouse Vegan Ingredients

The secret to that silky, non-sticky magic is in its vegan formula, which is loaded with natural butters and oils. This is what really separates it from so many basic drugstore balms.

These are the key players doing all the heavy lifting:

• Shea Butter: A classic for a reason. It delivers serious moisture and does a great job soothing and repairing dry, chapped lips.

• Murumuru Seed Butter: Sourced from the Amazon, this butter is packed with vitamins and oleic acid that help support your lips' natural moisture barrier to keep hydration locked in.

• Vegan Waxes: This is what gives the balm its structure and smooth glide without using beeswax. It’s a big part of what creates that unique melt-on-contact texture.

These ingredients work as a team to create a product that doesn’t just put a temporary layer on your lips but actually nourishes them over time.

A great lip balm should feel like skincare for your lips. The Summer Fridays formula nails this by combining rich, plant-based butters that offer both immediate comfort and long-term hydration—that's the gold standard we're judging every dupe against.

More Than Just a Balm

What really puts the Lip Butter Balm in a league of its own is that it's a true hybrid. It perfectly marries the deep, lasting hydration of a lip treatment with the pretty, polished look of a cosmetic.

The finish is incredibly high-shine, giving you a dewy, glass-like effect that could go head-to-head with most lip glosses. But—and this is a big but—it does it without any of the stickiness. That makes it comfortable enough to wear all day. This double-duty function is a huge piece of its appeal and a critical factor in our comparisons.

Price and Perceived Value

At $24 a tube, the Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm is definitely a premium beauty buy. While the price tag reflects the quality of the ingredients and chic branding, it's also the very reason we're all hunting for more affordable options.

The value of the original is rooted in its multitasking performance: it’s a balm, a gloss, and an overnight mask all in one tube. So, when we're testing a Summer Fridays lip butter balm dupe, we aren't just looking for something cheap. We’re looking for a product that can truly replicate this multi-functional magic at a fraction of the cost, which gives us a very clear benchmark for our comparisons.

The 7 Best Dupes for the Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm

After swatching, testing, and obsessing over dozens of contenders, the search for the perfect Summer Fridays lip butter balm dupe is officially over. We’ve found the top seven alternatives that truly deliver on that signature buttery texture, deep hydration, and juicy shine. From formulas that are practically twins to budget-friendly finds you can stash in every bag, there’s a perfect match for everyone.

1. Naturium Phyto-Glow Lip Balm

If you want the closest overall dupe in feel and finish, the Naturium Phyto-Glow Lip Balm is it. This is hands down the best Summer Fridays lip butter balm dupe on the market, masterfully replicating that luxurious, melty texture and high-shine look for a fraction of the price.

Texture and Finish
Naturium totally nailed the formula. This balm has the same silky, buttery glide as Summer Fridays, melting right into your lips without a hint of stickiness. The finish is a gorgeous, dewy gloss that makes your lips look plump and healthy. It feels lightweight yet deeply nourishing, hitting that perfect sweet spot between a balm and a gloss.

Hydration and Performance
Packed with plant-based butters and oils, this balm delivers fantastic hydration. It keeps lips feeling soft and moisturized for several hours. While it might not have the same overnight staying power as a thick treatment like Lanolips, it performs beautifully as a daily balm, providing consistent comfort and a polished look.

Shade and Scent Comparison
The shade range is where Naturium really shines. Its shade "Spice," a warm cinnamon brown, is an incredible dupe for Summer Fridays' viral "Brown Sugar." Likewise, "Petal" is a soft pink that gives "Pink Sugar" a run for its money. The scents are subtle and pleasant, adding to the experience without being overwhelming.

Key Ingredients and Value
The formula boasts shea butter, cupuaçu butter, and plant squalane—all known for their amazing moisturizing benefits. It’s also a vegan and cruelty-free formula, just like Summer Fridays. For only $10, the value is exceptional. This is our top recommendation for anyone who wants a near-identical experience without the luxury price tag.

2. Lanolips 101 Ointment Multi-Balm

When your lips are crying out for pure, unadulterated hydration, Lanolips 101 Ointment is a legend. It’s not a vegan formula like Summer Fridays, but its intense healing power makes it a top pick for anyone whose main goal is rescuing dry, chapped lips.

Texture and Finish
Lanolips has a much thicker, more viscous feel than the Lip Butter Balm. It’s richer and more substantial, coating your lips in a protective barrier that’s built to last. The finish is a healthy, natural-looking sheen—think repaired and cared-for, not the high-gloss, glass-like effect of Summer Fridays.

This is less of a makeup-balm hybrid and more of a dedicated treatment. It's the heavy-duty hero you grab when your lips need serious TLC.

Hydration and Performance
This is where Lanolips absolutely dominates. Its star ingredient, medical-grade lanolin, holds up to 400% of its weight in water, making its hydrating abilities truly exceptional. It gives you immediate relief from cracked lips and works to repair your moisture barrier over time. The wear time is incredible; you can put it on before bed and wake up with a comfortable, moisturizing layer still on your lips.

Shade and Scent Comparison
The original Lanolips 101 Ointment is clear and unscented, making it perfect as a base or an overnight mask. The brand also offers fun tinted and flavored versions like Strawberry and Coconutter, which give a sheer wash of color and a subtle, pleasant scent. While they won't directly match a shade like Vanilla Beige, they offer that same vibe of a natural, juicy tint.

If you're looking for the ultimate repair balm, Lanolips is unmatched. You choose this for its healing powers first and its looks second, making it an absolute must-have for anyone with chronically dry lips.

Key Ingredients and Value
The formula is built around ultra-pure lanolin, a natural emollient that mimics your skin's own oils. At around $14, it’s a great value because the formula is so concentrated—a tiny bit goes a very long way.

3. Milani Fruit Fetish Lip Oil

For those who live for a super glossy, juicy finish, the Milani Fruit Fetish Lip Oil is a fantastic choice. While it's technically an oil, its texture and performance sit perfectly between a traditional lip oil and a hydrating balm, making it a worthy dupe.

Texture and Finish
The Milani Lip Oil has a slightly thinner, slicker texture than the Summer Fridays balm, but it still feels plush and comfortable. It leaves an ultra-glossy, wet-look finish that instantly makes lips look fuller and more vibrant. Best of all, even though it’s an oil, it’s not greasy or sticky—just smooth, pleasant wear.

Hydration and Performance
Formulated with fruit extracts and Vitamin E, this product is more than just a pretty gloss. It provides a decent amount of hydration that leaves lips feeling soft and conditioned. Its main strength, though, is that incredible shine. It's an excellent topper over lipstick or a perfect standalone gloss for a pop of color and sheen. You might need to reapply it more often than a true balm to keep up the hydration, but for daily wear, it's solid.

Shade and Scent Comparison
Each shade has a matching fruity scent that’s sweet but not sickly. The tints are sheer but you can build them up for a more noticeable wash of color. The shade "Passionfruit Coconut" gives a nude-pink tint that really captures the everyday vibe of Summer Fridays' lighter shades.

Key Ingredients and Value
The formula is vegan and cruelty-free, featuring nourishing ingredients that condition the lips. At around $11, it's an affordable drugstore find that delivers a high-end glossy look, making it a great deal for shine-lovers.

4. e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm

Looking for the ultimate budget-friendly Summer Fridays lip butter balm dupe? Here it is. The e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm, at its ridiculously low price, manages to deliver a surprisingly similar experience. It’s a true standout in the drugstore aisle.

Texture and Finish
This balm has a smooth, creamy texture that feels comfortable and hydrating right away. It glides on easily and leaves a subtle, healthy-looking shine. It's not quite as glassy as Summer Fridays, but it’s super flattering for an everyday look. Plus, it's non-sticky and feels pleasantly lightweight.

Hydration and Performance
Infused with shea butter, hyaluronic acid, and goji berry, the e.l.f. balm provides a good hit of moisture. It keeps lips feeling soft and prevents dryness throughout the day. It’s not an intensive overnight treatment, but as a reliable daily hydrator, it performs way better than its price tag suggests.

Shade and Scent Comparison
The Squeeze Me Lip Balms come in several sheer, tinted shades with matching scents. "Vanilla Frosting" is a clear option that’s a great stand-in for the original clear Summer Fridays balm. Fun shades like "Strawberry" and "Grape" offer a playful hint of color and fragrance. The tints are subtle, perfect for a no-makeup makeup look.

Key Ingredients and Value
The addition of hyaluronic acid is a nice touch for a balm this affordable, as it helps draw in and hold onto moisture. It's also vegan and cruelty-free, which is a huge plus. At just $4, the value is simply unbeatable. This is the perfect dupe to throw in every bag without worrying if you lose it.

5. Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment

Created by Hailey Bieber, the Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment became a viral sensation for a reason—it shares a lot of qualities with the Summer Fridays balm. It’s a fantastic option for anyone who wants a high-performance, aesthetically pleasing balm with some added skincare perks.

Texture and Finish
The texture of the Rhode Lip Treatment is rich, smooth, and seriously glossy. It feels incredibly nourishing and creates a thick, cushiony layer on the lips that looks and feels luxurious. The finish is extremely high-shine, giving lips that plump, "glazed" look that lasts for hours.

Hydration and Performance
This is where Rhode really excels. The formula is made not just to hydrate but also to protect and restore the lip barrier. It provides deep, long-lasting moisture, making it great for both daily wear and as an intensive overnight mask. The peptides in the formula also aim to improve the look of lip volume and smoothness over time.

Shade and Scent Comparison
The original version is unscented, but Rhode has since released flavored options like Salted Caramel and Watermelon Slice. The tinted versions offer beautiful, sheer washes of color that are very on-trend. "Ribbon," a sheer pink, is a lovely alternative to Summer Fridays' "Pink Sugar."

Key Ingredients and Value
With key ingredients like shea butter, peptides, cupuaçu, and babassu, this formula is packed with powerhouse moisturizers and skin-restorers. At $16, it sits in a nice mid-range spot between drugstore dupes and Summer Fridays, offering excellent skincare-level benefits for the price.

6. Tree Hut Sugarlips Lip Butter

Most people know Tree Hut for their amazing body scrubs, but their Sugarlips Lip Butter is a true hidden gem. This product is an excellent dupe for anyone who loves a thick, rich, and deeply nourishing balm—especially for overnight use.

Texture and Finish
The Tree Hut Lip Butter has a dense, balmy texture that feels incredibly rich and comforting. It’s definitely thicker than Summer Fridays and feels more like a traditional lip mask. It melts on contact with your lips, leaving a subtle, natural-looking sheen rather than a super glossy finish.

Hydration and Performance
This balm is a hydration powerhouse. Its formula, rich in shea butter and rosehip oil, is designed to seal in moisture and repair dryness. It’s especially effective as an overnight treatment; you’ll wake up with lips that feel exceptionally soft, smooth, and plump. The thick texture creates a long-lasting protective barrier that really works.

Shade and Scent Comparison
The Sugarlips Lip Butter has a sweet, sugary scent that is pleasant and not at all overwhelming. It goes on clear, making it a versatile product that can be worn alone or layered over other lip products for an extra dose of moisture.

Key Ingredients and Value
The formula is built around shea butter, known for its deep moisturizing properties. For around $6, it offers incredible value for a product that performs as well as many high-end lip masks. It’s a must-try for anyone battling dry, flaky lips on a budget.

7. Tower 28 ShineOn Lip Jelly

Rounding out our list is the Tower 28 ShineOn Lip Jelly. While it's technically a gloss, its non-sticky, balmy formula makes it a fantastic Summer Fridays lip butter balm dupe for anyone who prioritizes a clean formula and a beautiful, glassy finish.

Texture and Finish
The Lip Jelly has the perfect gloss texture: it’s slick, smooth, and completely non-sticky. It feels like a nourishing balm but delivers the high-shine, mirror-like finish of a gloss. It’s also designed for sensitive skin, so it feels incredibly comfortable to wear.

Hydration and Performance
Formulated with a blend of five nourishing oils, including apricot kernel and raspberry seed oil, it provides a surprising amount of hydration for a gloss. It keeps lips feeling soft and moisturized while you wear it, combining color and care in one simple step.

Shade and Scent Comparison
Tower 28 offers a stunning range of sheer, milky, and shimmery shades. "Cashew," a sheer nude-pink, is a great dupe for "Vanilla Beige," while "Coconut" offers a pretty, rosy pink tint. The product is also fragrance-free, making it ideal for those with sensitivities.

Key Ingredients and Value
The formula is vegan, cruelty-free, and designed to meet the National Eczema Association's guidelines. The blend of plant-based oils ensures it's as good for your lips as it looks. Priced at $16, it’s a great mid-range option for a clean, high-performance lip product that mimics the glossy look of Summer Fridays.

The lip care market is booming, and that means more incredible alternatives for us. The United States lip care market alone is projected to grow at a CAGR of 7.7% from 2025 to 2035, jumping from USD 1,028.46 million to USD 2,180.86 million. With balms already making up 42.0% of the market, this growth fuels competition and innovation, leading to more affordable, high-quality dupes for everyone. You can discover more insights about the growing lip care market and its opportunities on Future Market Insights.

How The Dupes Actually Perform in Real Life

Product specs are one thing, but how a Summer Fridays lip butter balm dupe holds up through a morning coffee, a long day of meetings, or as an overnight treatment is what really matters. We put our top contenders through the paces in a few real-world tests to see which ones deliver when it counts.

Day-to-Day Wear and Longevity

For just running errands or sitting at your desk, you want a balm that feels great, looks good, and doesn't have you reapplying every thirty minutes. In this category, the Naturium Phyto-Glow Lip Balm and Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment were the clear standouts. Both kept their glossy finish and comfortable, hydrating feel for a few hours, fading away nicely without getting weird or patchy.

The Milani Fruit Fetish Lip Oil gave a gorgeous initial shine, but I found myself reaching for it more often to keep up both the gloss and the moisture. And while the e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm is a hydration hero for its price, it definitely had the shortest wear time of the group.

Overnight Lip Treatment

When your lips are screaming for some serious overnight TLC, the goal isn't just gloss—it's deep, lasting nourishment. This is where the thicker, richer formulas really get to shine.

If you want the closest dupe for texture and shine, the Naturium Phyto-Glow Lip Balm is a dead ringer. But for intense, long-haul repair, Lanolips is still the undisputed champ.

The Lanolips 101 Ointment and Tree Hut Sugarlips Lip Butter are absolute powerhouses here. Their dense formulas create a protective barrier that seals in moisture while you sleep. You'll wake up with lips that are noticeably softer and smoother, making them a must-have if you're battling serious dryness or chapping.

Performance Under Makeup

Using a balm under lipstick or with a liner is a delicate balance. You need hydration, but not so much slip that your color slides right off. If you need some pointers on getting that perfect shape, check out our guide on how to get bigger, fuller lips with lip liner techniques.

The Naturium balm is a fantastic base, smoothing everything out without messing with your lipstick's staying power. The Rhode treatment also works well, but its slightly thicker feel is probably best paired with just a lip liner for a defined, glossy pout.

To see how these balms stack up at a glance, I've broken down their key performance metrics.

Head-to-Head Performance Breakdown

Here’s a direct comparison of our top contenders against the original Summer Fridays balm. We rated each one on a scale of 1 to 5 for gloss and hydration, and timed how long they lasted in a typical wear test.

Product	Gloss Factor (1-5)	Hydration Level (1-5)	Longevity (Hours)
Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm	4.5	5	2-3
Naturium Phyto-Glow Lip Balm	4.5	4.5	2-3
Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment	4	5	3-4
Lanolips 101 Ointment	3	5	4+

As you can see, both Naturium and Rhode deliver a very similar experience in terms of gloss and hydration, with Rhode even pulling ahead slightly on longevity. Lanolips trades some shine for seriously impressive staying power, cementing its status as a treatment-focused balm.

Choosing a quality dupe can easily save you more than 50%, proving you don't need a premium price tag for high-performance lip care.

The Final Verdict on The Best Lip Butter Balm Dupe

After testing all these balms back-to-back, one thing is crystal clear: finding a fantastic Summer Fridays lip butter balm dupe is easier than ever. While the original is a cult classic for a reason, you can absolutely get a near-identical experience without the high-end price tag.

The "best" dupe really boils down to what you care about most. To make it simple, I’ve broken down my top picks by what they do best, so you can grab the one that fits your needs perfectly, whether that’s nailing the texture, saving the most money, or matching a specific shade.

The Best Overall Dupe

If you’re looking for the closest possible match in feel, shine, and the overall vibe, the Naturium Phyto-Glow Lip Balm is the hands-down winner. It just nails that silky, melt-into-your-lips texture and high-gloss finish that everyone loves about the Summer Fridays balm. The vegan formula feels incredibly luxurious and nourishing, making it our top pick for anyone who wants a near-perfect copy for less than half the price.

The Best Budget Dupe

For anyone who wants incredible value without feeling like you're skimping on quality, the e.l.f. Squeeze Me Lip Balm is the one to get. Seriously, at just $4, its performance is almost shocking. While the shine is a touch more subtle, it gives you solid hydration with a smooth, comfortable feel that isn't sticky at all. This is the perfect dupe to have stashed in every bag, car, and desk drawer.

Your perfect dupe comes down to your priorities. For a near-identical feel, grab Naturium. For an unbeatable price, choose e.l.f. For a specific tint match, find the corresponding shade in the Naturium line.

The Best Shade Match Dupe

Trying to replicate a specific tint can be the trickiest part of finding a good dupe, but again, Naturium Phyto-Glow Lip Balm comes out on top. Its shade "Spice" is a dead ringer for the viral "Brown Sugar," and "Petal" is a gorgeous alternative to "Pink Sugar." The color payoff and undertones are so close, making it the best choice if you're trying to replace your favorite Summer Fridays shade.

The lip balm world is always changing, and right now, the push is toward clean, effective formulas that feel good and do good. This trend means more brands are creating seriously high-quality products, making amazing dupes like these more common. You can read the full research on lip balm market trends and segments to see where the industry is heading.

FAQ: Your Questions About Summer Fridays Dupes Answered

We get it. The world of dupes is wild, and finding a good one can feel like looking for a needle in a haystack. So, let’s clear up some of the most common questions about the Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm and its affordable alternatives.

Is The Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm Actually Worth The Price?

Ah, the $24 question. The honest answer? It depends on what you're looking for. There’s no denying the original balm is a beautiful product. The packaging is chic, the formula is silky smooth, and it delivers on its promises. For a lot of people, that whole luxury experience makes the price tag worth it. But as our list proves, you can find a Summer Fridays lip butter balm dupe that gives you that same buttery, high-shine, and hydrating feel for less than half the price. If you’re all about performance and getting the most bang for your buck, a great dupe is the smarter move.

What is the closest dupe for Summer Fridays lip balm?

The closest dupe overall for the Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm is the Naturium Phyto-Glow Lip Balm. It masterfully replicates the signature buttery, non-sticky texture and the high-shine, glossy finish. The shade range is also excellent, with colors like "Spice" and "Petal" being near-perfect matches for popular Summer Fridays tints like "Brown Sugar" and "Pink Sugar."

What are the key ingredients to look for in a dupe?

A great dupe has to do more than just look similar in the tube. To get that same nourishing feel, look for key ingredients like shea butter, murumuru butter, plant-based oils (like jojoba or coconut), and vegan waxes. These are the components that deliver deep hydration and create that signature smooth, melty texture without feeling sticky.

Are these dupes vegan and cruelty-free?

Yes! Summer Fridays is proudly vegan and cruelty-free, and thankfully, many of the best dupes follow the same standards. Brands like Naturium, e.l.f., Milani, Tower 28, and Tree Hut are all cruelty-free, and the specific lip products we’ve highlighted are also vegan. The one exception on our list is Lanolips, as its star ingredient, lanolin, is derived from sheep's wool. Always double-check the packaging if this is a priority for you.

Find Your Perfect Affordable Lip Balm

At the end of the day, you really don't have to splurge to get that hydrated, super glossy lip look. As we've seen, there are some incredible alternatives out there that give you a nearly identical experience without the luxury price tag. And while you're on the hunt for the perfect balm, you might also want to check out our guide to the best Tower 28 BeachPlease tinted balm dupes. We hope this guide helps you find your new go-to affordable lip treatment.

After testing dozens of contenders, it's clear that the Naturium Phyto-Glow Lip Balm is the best Summer Fridays lip butter balm dupe. It flawlessly mimics the luxurious texture, high-shine finish, and deep hydration of the original for less than half the price, making it the undeniable winner. Whether you prioritize a perfect formula match, a specific shade, or just incredible value, the options on this list prove you can achieve that coveted buttery lip without breaking the bank.