Top Redken All Soft Dupe Hair Products 2026
You buy Redken All Soft because your hair feels better almost immediately. It’s softer, less rough, easier to detangle, and noticeably smoother through the mid-lengths. Then the bottle runs low, you look at the replacement cost, and suddenly the hunt for a redken all soft dupe starts.
The problem is that most dupe roundups stop at ingredient overlap. That’s useful, but it doesn’t answer the question consumers care about. Does the softness hold up after a few weeks, or does the hair start feeling coated, limp, or dry again?
Your Guide to The Best Redken All Soft Dupes
A lot of shoppers aren’t looking for a random moisturizing shampoo. They want the same finish that made All Soft popular in the first place. Hair that feels cushioned, smoother through the ends, and less frizzy without turning flat by day two. That’s also why long-term performance matters more than a simple dupe score.
That gap is real. A gap analysis found 0% of existing dupe content covered long-term testing, while searches for “Redken All Soft dupe 1 month review” rose 45% year over year according to SkinSort’s Redken All Soft dupe page. People want more than a screenshot of shared ingredients.
This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission if you purchase through my links, at no extra cost to you. Please read the disclosure policy for more information.
If you’re also weighing moisture versus softness versus salon feel, the comparison gets even more useful when you look at adjacent formulas and brand positioning, like in this Redken vs Pureology comparison.
Redken All Soft Dupe Quick Comparison
| Best Dupe | Best For | Approx. Savings |
|---|---|---|
| L'Oréal EverPure Deep Nourish Shampoo | Dry, brittle, color-treated hair | Roughly 65% less per ounce |
| Matrix Food For Soft Hydrating Shampoo | Closest formula feel and longer-lasting softness | Lower price point |
| L'Oréal Professionnel Absolut Repair Shampoo | Shoppers prioritizing ingredient similarity | More affordable alternative |
| Pureology Hydrate Shampoo | Fine to medium hair that needs moisture without heaviness | Qualitative savings vs salon splurges |
| Biolage HydraSource Shampoo | Thick, dry, frizz-prone hair | Qualitative savings vs premium salon formulas |
| OGX Renewing + Argan Oil of Morocco Shampoo | Tight budgets and easy drugstore access | Budget-friendly alternative |
The Science Behind Redken All Softs Cult Status
You notice it after the third or fourth wash, not the first. Hair still feels pliable at the ends, the mid-lengths stay smoother overnight, and frizz does not rebound the minute humidity shows up. That longer-wear softness is why Redken All Soft keeps its following.
Redken built the formula around a mix of cleansing, slip, and surface smoothing. Argan oil helps with the softer, conditioned feel. Dimethicone gives that polished glide people usually describe as salon-smooth. Sodium Laureth Sulfate keeps the shampoo from feeling too cushiony or hard to rinse, which matters because a moisture shampoo still has to clean well enough to avoid flat, coated roots.
What your hair actually feels from this formula
All Soft gives a specific finish. Hair feels softer, but also more obedient. Brushes move through the lengths faster, ends look less frazzled, and blowouts usually hold a smoother shape with less fluff.
That balance is harder to copy than it looks on an ingredient list.
A lot of hydrating shampoos can make hair feel nice in the shower, then leave it swollen once dry. Others go heavy on silicones and oils, so hair feels silky on day one but starts looking limp by the end of the week. All Soft usually sits in the middle. It gives enough coating for dry, porous, heat-styled hair, while still rinsing clean enough for many medium-density hair types to keep using it regularly.
Hair type decides whether that trade-off feels ideal. Thick, dry, color-treated hair often responds well to this kind of formula because the smoothing layer helps the cuticle stay flatter between washes. Very fine hair, low-density hair, or scalps that get oily quickly may like the immediate slip but find the overall routine too rich if the conditioner and leave-in are also heavy.
Why dupes often miss the mark
The strongest dupes copy the performance balance, not just a few matching ingredients. In testing, the misses usually show up over time. Some wash too clean, so softness fades after one day and ends start feeling rough again by week two. Others leave enough residue that hair seems softer at first, then loses movement and needs a clarifying wash sooner.
That is why I judge a redken all soft dupe over several weeks of use. I want to see whether softness holds, whether frizz stays down on non-wash days, and whether the formula still behaves well once a little buildup is inevitable. Those points matter more than a high similarity score if your goal is to replace the experience, not just the INCI list.
If you compare shampoos by finish and wear time, not just brand tier, this Olaplex vs Ouai shampoo comparison is useful for seeing how formula personality changes the result on real hair.
Dupe 1 LOréal EverPure Deep Nourish Shampoo
If you want the best all-around answer fast, this is the one I’d start with. L'Oréal EverPure Deep Nourish Shampoo is the dupe that gets closest to the experience people usually want from All Soft. Softness, smoother texture, and better frizz control without feeling like you need a salon-only bottle to get there.
Why it works
L'Oréal EverPure Deep Nourish shares key conditioning agents with Redken All Soft, including amodimethicone and citric acid. Beyond these shared ingredients, hands-on testing found that it effectively mimics Redken’s smoothness and frizz control on brittle hair while costing roughly 65% less per ounce, according to SkinSkool Beauty’s Redken All Soft dupe comparison.
That overlap matters because amodimethicone is one of the ingredients that gives hair that coated-but-smooth salon feel. Citric acid helps support a smoother cuticle feel. The result is hair that usually feels less rough after rinsing, and easier to detangle once dry.
Long-term performance notes
EverPure earns its place. Over repeated use, it tends to hold onto that soft, polished result better than many drugstore moisturizing shampoos. On dry or processed hair, it usually keeps the ends feeling manageable instead of fluffy.
It’s a better fit for people whose main complaint is roughness and frizz, not heavy oil or scalp buildup. If your hair is highlighted, color-treated, or naturally dry, this style of formula usually makes more sense than a squeaky-clean shampoo that strips too much from the lengths.
Biggest advantage: It gives a close version of the All Soft finish without forcing you into a premium-price repurchase cycle.
The trade-offs
No dupe is exact, and this one has limits.
- Less clarifying feel: If you have an oily scalp or use a lot of styling products, it may not feel as freshly cleansed as a richer salon shampoo with stronger cleansing power.
- Best on drier hair types: Fine hair can still use it, but very fine strands may need a lighter conditioner afterward.
- Not an exact texture match: The finish is similar, but not identical. Redken still has a slightly more polished salon feel.
A quick visual review can help if you want to see the product texture and positioning in action.
Who should buy this one
Choose EverPure if your hair sounds like this:
- Dry and brittle: You want softness first, not a deep-clean scalp reset.
- Color-treated: You want a gentler-feeling option that still smooths well.
- Frizz-prone: You need help with puffiness and rough ends after air drying or heat styling.
- Budget-conscious: You want the best value-to-performance ratio on this list.
If your hair gets weighed down easily, use a small amount and keep conditioner from the roots. If your scalp runs oily, alternate with a lighter or clarifying shampoo instead of using this every single wash.
Dupe 2 Matrix Food For Soft Hydrating Shampoo
Matrix Food For Soft Hydrating Shampoo is the option I’d point to if you want the closest thing to a formula-driven dupe, not just a cheap moisturizing shampoo. It behaves like a deliberate All Soft alternative.
Why ingredient match fans like it
Matrix Food For Soft shares 28 ingredients with Redken All Soft, including amodimethicone, citric acid, and tocopherol. Community benchmarks also note that it matches Redken’s moisture retention for up to 72 hours and offers comparable anti-frizz performance, according to SkinSort’s Matrix Food For Soft vs Redken All Soft comparison.
That doesn’t automatically make it the winner for everyone, but it does explain why the finish feels more intentional than a lot of lower-cost swaps. This is a high-similarity dupe with enough conditioning support to satisfy people who care about both feel and formula.
What it does better than expected
Matrix tends to perform especially well on hair that stays dry between washes. If your hair usually looks fine on wash day and then turns rough or poofy the next morning, this kind of longer moisture hold is where it shines.
I also like it for people who want softness without that “too creamy” sensation some rich shampoos leave behind. It smooths well, but it doesn’t immediately feel dense on the hair in the way some heavy moisture formulas can.
For shoppers who want a redken all soft dupe based on both shared ingredients and how the softness lasts, Matrix is the strongest runner-up.
Where it beats EverPure, and where it doesn’t
Compared with EverPure, Matrix is the more convincing pick if you care about formula closeness and sustained moisture. Compared with Redken, it gets surprisingly near on the anti-frizz side.
But there are trade-offs.
| Comparison point | Matrix Food For Soft | Best fit |
|---|---|---|
| Formula similarity | Higher-feeling match | Ingredient-focused shopper |
| Long-lasting softness | Strong | Dry, coarse, frizz-prone hair |
| Lightweight feel | Good, but still rich | Medium to thick hair |
| Budget feel | Better than salon premium | Value without going ultra-cheap |
Best hair types for Matrix
This one makes the most sense for:
- Medium to thick dry hair: It gives enough smoothing support to matter.
- Frizz-prone texture: It helps if your hair expands in humidity or after blow-drying.
- Heat-styled hair: It leaves a smoother surface feel that works well if you straighten or diffuse regularly.
- Shoppers who care about technical similarity: The ingredient overlap is one of its strongest selling points.
It’s less ideal if your roots get oily quickly and you like a very fresh, airy shampoo feel. In that case, EverPure may still be easier to live with, especially if you wash often.
Three More Worthy Redken All Soft Alternatives
You wash with a dupe for a week, love the first blowout, then wonder why your ends feel dry again by wash three. That drop-off matters more than a near-match ingredient list. These alternatives earned their place because they suit specific hair types and hold up differently over several weeks of use.
L'Oréal Professionnel Absolut Repair Shampoo
L'Oréal Professionnel Absolut Repair is the salon-leaning option I suggest for hair that feels rough from heat styling, bleach, or repeated glossing services. Earlier ingredient comparisons in this guide already show why people group it with All Soft. In actual use, the bigger question is how your hair feels after two to three weeks, not after one soft wash.
On damaged medium to thick hair, it usually keeps the cuticle feeling smoother longer than many cheaper moisture shampoos. On fine hair, it can cross into too much too fast, especially if you already use a rich mask or leave-in.
Best for:
- Damaged, rough lengths
- Medium to thick hair that likes salon formulas
- Shoppers who want softness with a more polished finish
Trade-offs:
- Less budget-friendly than true drugstore swaps
- Can feel heavy on fine or low-density hair
- Works best if your dryness comes from damage, not just mild dehydration
Pureology Hydrate Shampoo
Pureology Hydrate fits a narrower lane, but it fits it well. I reach for this type of formula when someone wants softness without the coated, overly cushioned feel that richer shampoos can leave behind.
It tends to suit fine to medium, color-treated hair better than the heavier options in this guide. Over time, that means better bounce at the root and less risk of day-two flatness. The trade-off is simple. You get controlled hydration, not the plush, buttery finish that makes All Soft so popular in the first place.
Best for:
- Fine to medium dry hair
- Color-treated hair that fades or feels fragile
- Anyone who wants softer lengths without sacrificing movement
What to expect:
- Less richness than All Soft
- Better root lift than heavier dupes
- May need a stronger conditioner or mask if your ends are heavily processed
Biolage HydraSource Shampoo
Biolage HydraSource makes the most sense for hair that stays thirsty no matter how carefully you wash it. Thick, coarse, or frizz-prone hair often responds better to this kind of moisture-first formula than to a more technical dupe that looks good on paper but fades fast in real life.
In testing, this type of shampoo usually gives better day-to-day manageability than exact dupe credibility. Hair tangles less. Air-dried texture looks calmer. The softness may feel a little less sleek than Redken, but if your main problem is bulk, dryness, and puffiness, that is a fair trade.
Best for:
- Coarse or thick hair
- Frizz-prone lengths
- Dry hair that gets puffy after air drying
Trade-offs:
- Too rich for very fine hair
- More moisture-focused than glossy-salon polished
- Can leave soft roots feeling flatter if you overapply
OGX Renewing + Argan Oil of Morocco Shampoo
OGX is the practical budget buy. It is easy to find, easy to replace, and good enough for shoppers who want softer hair without paying salon prices every month.
I would not call it the closest Redken substitute in formula behavior. I would call it the easiest entry point. On normal to slightly dry hair, it gives a smoother feel and decent shine for the price. On very dry or processed hair, the softness usually does not last as long unless you pair it with a stronger treatment, such as an argan oil hair mask for dry, damaged strands.
Best for:
- Tight budgets
- Normal to mildly dry hair
- Shoppers who want an easy argan-oil-based option
Where it falls short:
- Less lasting softness on very dry ends
- Simpler formula feel than salon picks
- Needs stronger support products if your hair is heavily processed or extension-wear adds extra dryness
If you wear extensions, product choice gets even pickier because too much richness can cause slip while too little leaves the added hair rough. A good stylist's guide to extension aftercare can help you choose a softer wash routine without shortening the life of the hair.
How to Maximize Results With Your Dupe
A dupe can get close, but your routine decides whether it stays close. Most of the disappointments people have with a redken all soft dupe come from using too much product, applying conditioner too high up, or expecting one shampoo to fix damage that really needs a mask or trim.
Start with application, not more product
Use a small amount first and emulsify it in wet hands before it hits your scalp. That gives you better distribution and usually helps rich shampoos lather more evenly.
Then focus the wash where oil builds up.
- Scalp first: Massage at the roots and crown where buildup sits.
- Let the suds travel: Pulling shampoo aggressively through the lengths can make dry ends rougher.
- Rinse longer than you think: Residue is one of the fastest ways to make a softening shampoo feel heavy.
Pair the dupe with the right support products
Conditioner placement matters more than often assumed. Keep it from the mid-lengths down, and be especially careful around the crown if your hair is fine.
For better results over time:
- Use a mask weekly if your hair is highlighted, heat-styled, or naturally dry.
- Alternate shampoos if your scalp gets oily but your ends stay dry.
- Use a lighter leave-in on fine hair and a richer cream on coarse hair.
If your lengths need more cushion than your shampoo can provide, a dedicated mask usually closes the gap better than buying a more expensive cleanser. A good example is this review of the Argan Magic Hair Mask, which fits the same softness-first goal many All Soft fans are chasing.
Adjust for extensions and fragile lengths
Extension wearers need to be more selective. A rich shampoo can help with softness, but application has to stay controlled around bonds, tapes, or sewn areas. If that’s your situation, this stylist's guide to extension aftercare is worth reading because it breaks down the kind of maintenance habits that keep added hair from drying out or tangling.
Practical rule: The more processed your hair is, the less useful “strong cleansing” becomes as your everyday shampoo strategy.
The best dupe routine usually looks boring on paper. Gentle wash, targeted conditioning, one solid mask, and less overwashing. That’s what keeps the softness going.
Frequently Asked Questions About Redken Dupes
Some dupe questions come up every time, especially around color safety, buildup, and whether a cheaper option can really replace a salon favorite long term. The short answer is yes, sometimes, but only if the dupe matches your hair type.
FAQ
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Is the best redken all soft dupe always the closest ingredient match? | No. Ingredient overlap helps, but long-term feel matters more. A shampoo can look close on paper and still wear too heavy, too flat, or not soft enough for your hair type. |
| Which dupe is best for color-treated hair? | L'Oréal EverPure Deep Nourish Shampoo is the easiest starting point if you want softness and smoother texture without a harsh-feeling wash. |
| Which option is best for thick, dry hair? | Matrix Food For Soft Hydrating Shampoo or Biolage HydraSource Shampoo are usually better fits when hair needs more sustained moisture and frizz control. |
| Will a dupe lather the same way as Redken All Soft? | Not always. Some feel creamier, some feel lighter, and some give less of that salon-lather experience. Lather differences don’t automatically mean worse performance. |
| Can a dupe make fine hair greasy? | Yes, if the formula is too rich for your roots or if conditioner is applied too high. Fine hair usually does best with careful product placement and occasional rotation with a lighter shampoo. |
| What if my hair feels soft at first, then heavy after a few weeks? | That usually points to buildup or a formula mismatch. Reduce product, rinse more thoroughly, and alternate with a lighter cleanser if your scalp needs more freshness. |
The quick rule I use
Pick by hair behavior, not hype.
If your hair is dry and brittle, start with EverPure. If it’s thicker and frizz-prone, Matrix is often the better call. If your budget is tight, OGX is the easiest low-risk entry point. If you care most about salon-style formula closeness, Absolut Repair deserves a look.
The Verdict Our Top Redken All Soft Dupe
The best overall redken all soft dupe is L'Oréal EverPure Deep Nourish Shampoo.
It wins because it closely matches the desired replacement qualities: softness, smoother texture, and frizz control. It achieves this without requiring premium salon prices. It also suits the broadest range of dry, brittle, and color-treated hair types, which makes it the safest recommendation for most readers.
Matrix Food For Soft Hydrating Shampoo is the best runner-up. If you want a more technical match and longer-lasting moisture, it’s the stronger choice. For some thicker or rougher hair types, it may even be the better personal fit.
The bigger takeaway is simple. You don’t need the original bottle to get the result you loved. The right dupe can keep hair soft, manageable, and polished, especially if you choose based on long-term performance instead of ingredient lists alone.
If you love saving money on beauty without settling for second-best, Finding Favourites is worth bookmarking. It’s packed with practical dupe guides, honest comparisons, and budget-friendly swaps that help you skip the trial-and-error.